Police raid fatalities in Rio revive debate over
policy
Police action in Rio de Janeiro claimed 10 fatalities
in a single day in early February, as governor Sérgio Cabral pressed ahead with
his strong-arm anticrime drive which has brought down Rio state's murder rate by
about 10% — but has also prompted renewed criticism of the Rio police for its
trigger happy inclination. Almost simultaneously in São Paulo, the killing of a
suspected robber by police led to violent protest riots, quelled by large-scale
police repression that left many — mostly police officers — injured by
gunfire.
The shootings in Rio took place on 4 February, when 300
police officers — a combined force of the military and civil police backed up by
helicopters and an armoured vehicle — raided four favelas in the west of the
city (Coréia, Taquaral, Rebu and Vila Aliança) to execute arrest warrants issued
against suspected drug traffickers.
Five of those killed had, according to the police,
opened fire on the officers as they prepared to raid a house. They were
identified as gunmen in the pay of a drug-trafficking gang. Another two, also
identified as criminals, were killed in gunfire exchanges elsewhere. Three more,
also identified as narco gunmen, were killed as they were returning to the area
and ran into a departing group of policemen.
Seven of those killed were between 18 and 24 years old;
one was 16, another 15, and the only older victim was 37. The police managed to
make seven arrests and seized seven pistols, one revolver, two grenades, two
radio transmitters and an unspecified amount of cocaine.
Deaths at the hands of Rio police averaged just under
four a day in 2008, and totalled about 6% more than in 2007. Last October,
Philip Alston, the UN special rapporteur on arbitrary, summary or extrajudicial
executions, issued a report strongly criticising the frequent recourse by the
Rio police to 'summary executions', often classified as 'resistance followed by
death', which often remain unpunished. Amnesty International also criticised the
force for its 'indiscriminate killing' of civilians.
Governor Cabral, however, has defended his strong-arm
policy by pointing out that it has reduced Rio de Janeiro's murder rate to the
lowest level since statistics began to be compiled in 1991. He has promised not
to relent, saying, 'Those who believe that with discourses alone they can
confront bandits strongly armed with rifles and grenades are mistaken.'
A day before the Rio police operation, 160 police
officers backed up by 60 patrol cars and motorcycle units descended upon the
Paraisópolis favela in the Morumbí district of São Paulo (which also has some of
the wealthiest quarters of the city) to repress violent riots that had been
raging for almost a day. The riots were a response to the killing by police of a
suspected robber: neighbours took to the streets, barricaded access routes with
flaming tyres, held up passing drivers and torched cars. Three police officers
were injured by gunfire, as was an onlooker. Another policeman was badly hurt by
a stone.
The police arrested nine persons, who were later
released, and said that a hunt was on for the instigators of the rioting, which
they said were probably local criminals. The state's public security secretariat
announced that the police contingent would remain in Paraisópolis 'for as long
as necessary'; they were withdrawn a day later.