Brazil-US defence cooperation agreement
Development: On 7 April the Brazilian ministry of foreign affairs announced the completion of a new defence cooperation agreement with the US.
Significance: The brief Itamaraty Palace press release was clear that all the other members of the Union of South American Nations (Unasur, comprising the 12 South American countries) were informed about the deal which, it also stressed, “contains an express clause of guarantees that ensure respect for the principles of the sovereign equality of states, territorial integrity and inviolability, and non-intervention in the internal affairs of other states". This clause is in line with a resolution adopted by the Unasur defence council on 27 November 2009 and, the Brazilian government hopes, will pre-empt any hostile reactions to the agreement by the likes of Venezuela's President Hugo Chávez .
The succinct Brazilian statement contrasts with the apparent inability of the US state department to explain properly and clearly its Latin America policy messages. Since President Barack Obama took office and heralded “a new era" in US-Latin American relations, there has been nothing but confusion in the region as to what, if anything, has changed.
To date, the mixed messages emanating from the US government has allowed the radical Left in the region to (re) interpret and shape regional perceptions of US policy under Obama - helped by the clumsy US handling of the six-month long Honduras coup crisis.
According to the Itamaraty, the agreement, which is expected to be signed by Brazil's defence minister Nelson Jobim and the US defence secretary Robert Gates early next week, is designed to “strengthen the dialogue between the two countries and open new prospects for cooperation in this field [defence], on a balanced and mutually beneficial basis".
It aims to: “improve the institutional coverage for existing and future bilateral cooperation in areas such as: a) visits by high level delegations, b) technical level contacts, c) meetings between defence institutions, d) exchanges of students, instructors and training personnel, e) training and development events, f) ship visits, g) sporting and cultural events, h) commercial initiatives related to defence, and i) programs and projects in defence technology."
When news of the deal was first leaked by the daily O Estado de São Paulo it was spun as a military base accord. O Estado reported that following a visit on 30 March to Brazil by the Commander of the US Southern Command, General Douglas Fraser, where he met Jobim and the head of Brazil's federal police, Luiz Fernando Corrêa, a new “multinational, multifunctional" base in Rio de Janeiro would monitor, control and combat drugs trafficking, arms trafficking, contraband flows and terrorism in the South Atlantic. That story prompted immediate fevered speculation about the possibility of US troops being stationed in Brazil.
Days earlier, the US ambassador to Colombia, William Brownfield, had announced that the US was on the verge of signing “military cooperation agreements" with two countries in Latin America. His remarks prompted Venezuela's President Chávez immediately to proclaim the proposed new accords to be “a clear threat".
The top US diplomat for the region, the Chilean-born Assistant Secretary of State for Western Hemisphere Affairs, Arturo Valenzuela, has spent much of his regional tour this week trying to address the speculation about the new deal. On Tuesday (6 April) in Bogotá, Colombia, Valenzuela insisted (in Spanish), “no-one has talked about installing US military bases in Brazil". He stressed that the US was discussing “security cooperation agreements" similar to accords it has in place with countries all over the world. He said that the idea had come about as a result of US-Brazilian co-operation in Haiti, where the Brazilian military heads up the United Nations stabilisation mission (Minustah).
What is clear from the Brazilians - and what Valenzuela and his colleagues have not conveyed with the necessary clarity - is that the agreement is not in any shape or form a replica of the controversial 'Defence Cooperation Agreement' signed by the US and Colombia in October 2009 - widely understood to grant the US access to seven Colombian bases (although it is, in fact, less limiting than this).
According to the Brazilians, any new 'facility' (it will expressly not be a military base) will be under Brazilian command. It will complement two others - one in Key West, Florida (the US Southern Command's Joint Interagency Task Force South), which monitors the Caribbean, and another in Lisbon, Portugal, which covers the North Atlantic. The US - and other countries - would post 'attachés' (military, police or intelligence officers) to the facility, where they would work under Brazilian management. The Key West facility includes representatives of Argentina, Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru and other Latin American countries.
The Brazilian press note that the deal is the first major bilateral defence accord since 1977, when Brazil unilaterally withdrew from a previous 1952 accord.