Bolivia shaken by domestic spying revelations
The Bolivian government has ordered an overhaul of the national police's
intelligence activities, following revelations that it had been involved in
'unauthorised' spying on politicians and journalists. It has suggested that the
US embassy may have exerted undue influence over 'irregular' police intelligence
agencies. Opposition leaders have instead suggested that the domestic spying
operations may have been conducted by Venezuelan and Cuban intelligence
personnel acting under police cover. The senate has summoned interior minister
Alfredo Rada to explain what has been going on.
The last week-and-a-half of January opened with the anonymous distribution to
two Bolivian newspapers and four television channels of evidence - in the form
of surveillance dossiers and photographs - that police intelligence agents had
been spying on at least 44 people, mostly politicians, but also journalists.
Among the most prominent targets were former president Jorge Quiroga, the
governors of Santa Cruz, Beni, Tarija and Cochabamba, opposition legislator
Óscar Ortiz, maverick congressman Gustavo Torrico of the ruling Movimiento al
Socialismo (MAS), and deputy news editor of the TV station Unitel, Juan José
Espada.
Interior minister Alfredo Rada promptly denied that anyone in the government
had ordered the police to conduct domestic spying operations and suggested that
the documents had been leaked to the media as part of an internal 'dirty war'
within the police officer corps, between factions backing different candidates
for promotion to general. Vice-president Álvaro García Linera also denied any
government involvement, adding the surprising claim that 'we have discovered
that we don't have one intelligence service, but two or three.' The
proliferation of police agencies performing intelligence tasks has actually been
well-known for a long time.
Rada took the cue and 'revealed' that there were 'irregular' intelligence
outfits within the police. He cited the Comando de Operaciones Especiales
(Copes), established 15 years ago with, he underlined, the logistical and
technological support of the US embassy. Rada said that in January 2006, when
President Evo Morales took office, this outfit was re-designated Organización
de Estudios Policiales (Odep), 'but we have discovered that it is Copes that has
continued to operate behind that name.' He also cited as a 'less irregular'
outfit the Grupo Especial Táctico de Investigaciones de Delitos (Getide), which
he said had engaged in activities beyond its formal brief of investigating
crime. Finally, he cited a third unit, the Grupo de Seguridad Anti-terrorista,
which he described as charged with the security of the US embassy.
Rada said the US embassy would be asked to inform about its links with these
units and whatever support it offers them, a remark widely interpreted as a
suggestion that the 'irregular' spying had been orchestrated by the US embassy.
He did not make any reference to the fact that the targets were predominantly
opposition politicians routinely accused by the government of being in league
with the US. The embassy said that all of its cooperation with Bolivian police
activities was conducted with the full knowledge of the government.
The chief of police, General Miguel Vásquez, went further than Rada or
García Linera, unambiguously admitting that police agents had engaged in spying
on politicians. He added, however, that he had not ordered this, and that the
person who should provide the answers was police intelligence chief, Colonel
José Luis Centellas. The government endorsed this passing of the buck: on 28
January García Linera publicly confirmed General Vásquez in his post, and
ordered him to clean up police intelligence activities, bringing them all under
the wing of the Dirección Nacional de Inteligencia (DNI).
The opposition governor of Cochabamba, Manfred Reyes Villa, claimed on 26
January that 'Cuban and Venezuelan nationals' had been identified among those
who had been spying on opposition politicians. Opposition senators, taking
General Vásquez's disclaimer at face value, said that his ignorance of what was
happening could only be explained by the 'Cuban and Venezuelan takeover' of
domestic intelligence-gathering. Two days after Reyes Villa's accusation, the
opposition-controlled senate announced that it was summoning minister Rada to
clarify this matter.