Chile’s two presidential candidates were holding events to close their respective campaigns in the capital Santiago as we went to press on 16 December, with just three days to go before the second-round presidential run-off. Gabriel Boric, representing the left-wing Apruebo Dignidad coalition, appears to have a slight advantage over his far-right opponent, José Antonio Kast from the Partido Republicano (PLR), who came two points ahead in the first round. But the race remains wide open, with much hinging upon which candidate will have been most successful in appealing to the undecided voters in the centre.
Boric and Kast offer radically different visions for Chile, and the presidential run-off has been painted in the media as a polarising contest between two extremes. Kast rejects being labelled as far-right, but he holds ultra-conservative social views, has campaigned on a discourse of law-and-order, and in the past expressed a favourable opinion of Augusto Pinochet’s dictatorship (1973-1990). He is often seen as being of the same mould as Brazil’s President Jair Bolsonaro or former US president Donald Trump.
Representing a new generation of progressive left-wing politics, Boric is far from being a radical, but his past as a leader in student protests, his support for the 2019 social uprising (which many on the right consider to have been a vandalism spree led by thugs), and his alliance with the more radical Partido Comunista de Chile (PCCh), have often led to him being depicted as representing the ideals of the far-left. He has more recently ascribed himself the label of social democrat.
The second-round campaign has indeed seen both candidates adopt a more moderate discourse, in a bid to attract the votes of the 3.3m voters who were disappointed in the first round (between them, Boric and Kast collected 3.8m votes; some 88,000 people cast blank or spoilt ballots, and turnout was just 47%). Whoever wins the run-off on 19 December will also have to work with a legislature dominated by the traditional centre-left and centre-right parties which fared so poorly at a presidential level [WR-21-47].
These parties have all re-aligned themselves behind one of the two candidates. The parties that make up the current governing coalition, which ran in the elections as Chile Podemos Más, are all backing Kast. The defeated Chile Podemos Más candidate, Sebastián Sichel, was more reluctant to come out in favour of Kast, but eventually announced his conditional support, after a request for moderating certain elements of the far-right candidate’s programme was accepted.
Boric, meanwhile, received the unconditional support of the Partido Socialista (PS) and Democracia Cristiana (DC). The defeated centre-left candidates who between them got 19.2% of the vote, the DC’s Yasna Provoste and Marco Enríquez-Ominami, a former PS member, were quick to announce that they will be backing Boric.
More recently, the left-wing candidate received a public declaration of support from former president Michelle Bachelet (2006-2010; 2014-2018). Bachelet, who is now the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, held a brief meeting with Boric on 12 December upon arriving in Chile; she formalised her support for him two days later, describing the upcoming election as “fundamental”.
Final debate inconclusive
The two candidates’ attempts to woo the centre were on display during the last presidential debate, organised by the national television association (Anatel) on 13 December. Perceived as the last opportunity to change the minds of undecided voters, the debate was a somewhat lukewarm affair.
The two candidates did clash, for example, over civil rights issues and Kast’s controversial views on sexual diversity, or when the far-right candidate evoked the allegations of sexual harassment that Boric has faced (and denies). But, overall, both candidates sought to push their more popular proposals and drive home their ‘moderate’ image.
“I don’t want to be a president with a raised fist, I want to be a president who talks and embraces,” Kast said. For his part, Boric insisted that he wants Chile to become a welfare state. “I’m not concerned by what label it is given. If it’s social democrat, then so be it,” he said. The debate covered, amongst other things, the candidates’ views on governability, drug trafficking, and pensions.
“I don’t think either of the two tripped up [in the debate],” Axel Callís, a sociologist and director of pollster Tú Influyes, said on the television news programme T13 in the wake of the debate. “Gabriel Boric showed that he is the man who is reading the moment and who will reach agreements, even with a hung parliament,” Callís maintained, while “José Antonio Kast showed himself to be a coherent person, holding the same line […] and who is therefore trustworthy”.
Public opinion polls cannot be published in the two weeks running up to a vote in Chile, but polls conducted privately continue to confirm Boric’s narrow lead over Kast. But his lead falls within most polls’ margin of error and the race is expected to be a close one.
The ‘kingmaker’
Francisco Parisi, the outsider candidate who successfully captured the protest vote to come third place in the first round with 12.8% of the vote, has been described as the ‘kingmaker’ for the second round. The US-based businessman, who is embroiled in allegations of various wrongdoing, and ran his entire campaign without setting foot in Chile, has not explicitly endorsed either candidate, although he seems to favour Kast. He hosted Kast for a cordial discussion on his ‘Bad Boys’ YouTube channel on 5 December. Boric declined an invitation to appear on the same channel a few days later, and Parisi instead recorded an episode criticising Boric’s government programme.
The CC
Whoever wins the presidential run-off will be in office when the constituent convention (CC), elected earlier this year to draft a new constitution for Chile, will present its proposal for the new magna carta (which will be voted upon in a referendum). Kast was opposed to the constituent process from the outset, whereas Boric – unlike his PCCh allies – supported it. The CC president Elisa Loncón, an indigenous academic, expressed her veiled support for Boric when she said, during a Mapuche meeting on 12 December: “Let us defend what we have achieved and opt for the proposal that is defending the new constitution, parity, the rights of nature, diverse sexual rights, the rights of women”.