Chile steps up pressure on Peru
Development: On 1 December Chile's rightwingers stepped up the pressure on Peru's president Alan García over his apparent recanting of his promise to sack Peru's army commander.
Significance: Chileans, probably accurately, believe that García is wavering over whether to sack General Edwin Donayre Gotzch because he wants to build up his popularity in Peru. In the Chileans' view García wants to boost his dismal popularity (under 20% in the opinion polls) by tapping into Peruvians' traditional hostility to Chile.
Hernán Larraín, a senator from Chile's rightwing Unión Democráta Independiente, said on 1 December that if García did not sack Donayre he would be endorsing the anti-Chilean views expressed by Donayre. Donayre was videoed, apparently drunk, making anti-Chilean remarks at a military party sometime in 2006. The video was broadcast on YouTube on 25 November 2008. Donayre said that he had given an order that any Chilean who entered Peru should go home in a coffin and if there were not enough coffins, plastic bags should be used. He also called on the ladies present at the party to turn themselves into ladybombs and seduce Chileans to help the Peruvian army.
Larraín said that if García failed to put Donayre on to the retired list, or to sack him, he would be endorsing the General's remarks, which Larraín implied, made the issue more serious. Larraín, who is a member of the senate's foreign relations committee, said that Donayre's remarks and the attitude of the Peruvian government are equally offensive to the Chilean people.
On 28 November the Chilean government said that García had promised President Michelle Bachelet, when he phoned her to apologise for Donayre's remarks, that Donayre would be put on to the retired list on 5 December. The Chilean government has said on several occasions, through either President Bachelet's spokesman or the foreign minister, Alejandro Foxley, that relations with Peru will not recover unless Donayre goes. The Peruvian government and Donayre, however, reacted furiously to these statements, protesting that Chile should not be giving orders to the Peruvian government.
Donayre himself tried to laugh off what he said and dismissed it as a piece of nonsense. At the weekend he claimed that he could remain in command of the Peruvian army for three or four more years.
Larraín challenged García to be man enough to do what he had promised to Bachelet: sack Donayre and issue a public apology to Chile. Larraín said that he supported calls, from other rightwingers, that the Chilean ambassador to Peru should be recalled for consultations. Larraín said that he did not believe relations should be broken off over this issue, though he did believe that they had been adversely affected.
Some in the Peruvian government clearly believe that Donayre must go. The defence minister, Antero Flores-Aráoz, who pulled out of a trip to Chile at the end of last week, said that military standing orders were that no officer could speak to the press without permission; Flores-Aráoz said, pointedly, that this applied to Donayre and he should be very careful about what he said.
On the other hand, Peru's
foreign minister, José Antonio García Belaunde, said that he believed that the
row would blow over. He admitted that Donayre's remarks were unfortunate, but he
also said that Chile's reaction was disproportionate.