ECUADOR: Hopes for reset in indigenous relations
Ecuador’s umbrella indigenous organisation Confederación de Nacionalidades Indígenas del Ecuador (Conaie) has been a potent foe of successive governments. Major indigenous protests against the current administration have so far been avoided since President Daniel Noboa took office in November 2023, but Conaie was nevertheless fiercely critical of the government under the leadership of Leonidas Iza (2021-2024). Iza was replaced as Conaie leader on 21 July by Marlon Vargas whose rise was welcomed by the Noboa administration as an opportunity to improve relations.
Conaie has over the past 30 years launched massive protests over social, economic, and environmental issues that at times threatened to topple the governments of President Noboa’s three immediate predecessors, Guillermo Lasso (2021-2023), Lenín Moreno (2017-2021), and Rafael Correa (2007-2017) and played an instrumental role in bringing down presidents Abdalá Bucaram in 1997, Jamil Mahuad in 2000, and Lucio Gutiérrez in 2005 before them.
Whilst the indigenous organisation has so far refrained from launching widespread protests against Noboa, it has grown increasingly strident in its criticism of his handling of the economy, his interest in partially privatising the oil sector, his plans to boost mining, and his efforts to secure the return of foreign military bases that were banned under Correa.
Despite intense opposition from the Conaie rank-and-file, Noboa’s congressional coalition hinges on the support of six deputies from the indigenous party Pachakutik – the political arm of Conaie. Slammed as traitors by Iza, these legislators were expelled from Conaie on 19 July for voting in favour of government bills. Their expulsion, which took place during the indigenous congress at which Vargas was elected leader, was the last major decision taken under Iza, highlighting the organisation’s mounting tensions with the government.
The Noboa administration appears hopeful that relations with Conaie will improve under Vargas, who won the leadership election with 617 votes against Iza’s 540. The minister for government, José de la Gasca, said on 22 July that the change of leadership at Conaie is “a very good thing” and said he was hopeful of “a change of direction” after Iza’s “authoritarian and despotic” tenure at the helm.
Vargas took a conciliatory step the previous day when he met with the six expelled Pachakutik deputies, who urged him to initiate the process of having their expulsion overturned. This has set the stage for a confrontation between the more moderate faction of Conaie, led by Vargas, and the hardline wing of the party led by Iza.
Conaie’s move away from the more radical stance advocated by Iza comes as the indigenous movement seems to be losing its sway with the wider public. Pachakutik had its best electoral performance in two decades in 2021, when its candidate, Yaku Pérez, took 19% of the vote and missed out on the second round of the presidential election by a whisker. Since then, however, the vote share taken by indigenous candidates has shrunk drastically. Pérez took just 4% in the following election in 2023. In the first round of this year’s presidential election in February, Iza was the party’s candidate and took 5%.
Pachakutik and Conaie will therefore need to decide how they fit into the new political context that has been forged since Noboa took office in 2023 as a self-proclaimed outsider, breaking the traditional left-right dynamic in which indigenous candidates presented themselves, with some success, as the third-way option.
Troops rushed to Manabí
On 18 July Ecuador’s defence ministry announced that nearly 2,000 additional troops had been deployed to the north-western province of Manabí, one of the provinces most impacted by gang violence due to its location in a key drug-trafficking corridor between the Colombian border and the port city of Guayaquil. The defence ministry said that the new troops would mostly be sent to the cities of Manta and Portoviejo. Local media reported that in the 12 hours before the announcement, 15 people had been murdered in Manabí.