Propped up by steady consumer spending and a decent performance by the agriculture sector, Mexico’s GDP rose at its fastest pace in two years in the third quarter in seasonally-adjusted terms. This created some optimism that, despite the severe economic toll of the continued oil price rout, a recovery is around the corner in 2016.
Real GDP rose by 0.8% quarter-on-quarter in the June-September period, according to the national statistics institute (Inegi), the best result since the third quarter of 2013, while in year-on-year terms, it expanded by 2.6%.
In the quarter-on-quarter comparison, agriculture was the best performing sector, posting growth of 2.3% over the second quarter. The services sector, as well as industry, rose by 0.8%; while the services sector has performed steadily all year, the latest result was a notable improvement for industry, which had stagnated in the first half.
In year-on-year terms, agriculture again posted the best result, with firm growth of 4.1%. Services expanded by 3.3%, with broad-based growth led by mass media (9.3%), hotels and restaurants (7.1%), culture and sport (5.3%), and retail and wholesale trade (4.8%). Analysts attributed the strength of hotel and restaurants to strong tourism activity this year, helped by a weaker peso/US dollar exchange rate, which makes Mexico cheaper for US tourists. By contrast, social services (education, health and government) posted only moderate growth in the third quarter (of less than 1% overall), likely reflecting a slowing of social spending after it was front-loaded in the first half ahead of midterm elections in June.
While the industrial sector registered growth of 1.2% in the third quarter, it was not broad-based. While utilities, construction and manufacturing were all in positive territory, manufacturing in fact posted its weakest year-on-year growth since 2013, at 2.8%, as the sector continues to perform erratically in line with the stop-start performance of Mexico’s main economic partner, the US. Meanwhile, mining - which includes the oil and gas sector – contracted by 5.6%, in line with the oil price crash and continued weakness in production.
Despite continued strong headwinds in the form of rock bottom oil prices and continued weakness in the key manufacturing sector, officials seized on the latest data with gusto. Deputy finance minister Fernando Aportela reaffirmed the government’s forecast for overall GDP growth of between 2% and 2.8% this year, rising to a range of 2.6%-3.6% in 2016, which is a little higher than the private sector consensus of between 2.8% and 3%. “In a complex, volatile environment, the Mexican economy is growing more than in the same period a year ago, at a faster pace than in the first half of this year and above analyst estimates. The economy has been driven mainly by the dynamism of the domestic market”, Aportela noted. The central bank (Banxico) governor, Augustín Carstens, was a little more cautious, attributing the “moderate” third quarter growth to a faster expansion in retail sales and consumer credit. On 4 November, Banxico in fact said that the economy would grow by 1.9%-2.4% this year, slightly moderating its previous forecast of 1.7%-2.5%.
The official hope is that a recovery will set in during 2016 on the back of fairly robust domestic fundamentals (including low inflation – see box below), and continued strengthening of the US economy, which should spur exports and investment. Investment should also rise in line with the continued liberalisation of Mexico’s energy and telecommunications sectors, as per the government’s flagship sectoral reforms, which over the next few years will generate sizeable new investment inflows.
Inflation remains low, despite heavy peso drop
The headline inflation index came in at 0.51% in the month of October, the sharpest monthly increase since November 2014. The 12-month rate remained low at 2.48%, however.
The October monthly result was driven up by a 3.3% month-on-month rise in energy prices, as many cities ended their lower seasonal summer tariff schemes. The price rise contributed almost a third (0.31%) to the headline result. Other contributory factors included a rise in prices for new cars and holiday packages – both of which are affected by the pass-through effect of the peso's depreciation against the US dollar. By contrast, gasoline prices continue to benefit from much lower fuel import costs, while the effects of the government’s liberalising reforms of the telecommunications sector are now being felt directly by Mexican consumers in the form of lower mobile phone tariffs, as providers race to offer more competitive packages.
On the year-on-year comparison, the 12-month inflation rate of 2.48% was a new record low. According to Inegi, this reflected a sharp fall in non-core inflation to 2.52% (from 2.96% in September), the lowest rate since March 2011, thanks largely to lower energy prices and, in turn, to significantly lower prices for some foodstuffs. Core inflation, by contrast, edged up a notch to 2.47%, from 2.38% in September, which Inegi said reflected the pass-through effect of the peso's depreciation. However, non-core and core inflation were similar in October – which analysts note is a positive, as it helps to anchor inflation expectations.
The consensus is for inflation to average less than 3% this year, before rising back towards 3.5%-4% in 2016, in line with a stronger economic recovery.
Both Banxico and private economists have emphasised the point that the pass-through to inflation from the peso's depreciation is relatively moderate compared to the sharp drop in the currency over the past year. This suggests that inflation has ‘decoupled’ from the peso.
By way of illustration, the peso has fallen by 17% against the US dollar, in the past year, but in the same period annual inflation has fallen from 4.2% to a record low of 2.4% in November. Citing calculations by Bank of America, financial wire Bloomberg on 24 November noted that, “the currency’s impact today is almost imperceptible, with each 1% decline in its value fuelling less than 0.05% of inflation. Two decades ago, when consumer prices soared over 20% in just four months, after the government devalued the exchange rate, the peso-to-inflation ratio was 10 times higher”.
While analysts are somewhat divided as to the causes, (there are both positive and negative interpretations, ranging, on the positive side, from Mexico’s hard-won inflation policy credibility and much stronger competition in the domestic retail market, to the negative fact that growth is still weak, depressing prices), this decoupling effect is important, as it not only protects consumer purchasing power but also affords the local monetary policy authorities much greater flexibility. Banxico has held its benchmark interest rate at a record low of 3% since last year, in stark contrast to the likes of successive hikes in Brazil and Colombia, for instance. Bloomberg notes that “Banxico in November released a study this month showing Mexico has the lowest pass-through ratio among major Latin American countries…And central bank Governor Augustin Carstens declared [in a recent op-ed] that the peso-inflation link is, by and large, dead”.
Indeed, the peso recently touched a record low of M$17.3/US$1, as global oil prices continue to falter, although it has since come back in slightly, trading at about M$16.5/US$1 as we went to press on 25 November. End box
According to Inegi, Mexico’s agri-food export basket was valued at US$20.3bn in the first nine months, an increase of 5.8% year-on-year over the same period of 2014. Mexico accumulated an agri-food trade surplus of US$1.1bn with the rest of the world in the same period.
- Pemex downgraded by Moody’s
Having put Mexico's state-owned oil company Pemex on downgrade watch in August, Moody’s Investors Service followed through on 24 November, citing lower earnings and rising debt levels. The ratings agency cut Pemex’s global rating to 'Baa1' from 'A3', two notches above the minimum investment grade. “Moody’s believes that Pemex’s credit metrics will deteriorate further in the short to medium term as oil prices remain depressed, production continues to drop, taxes remain high, and the company’s capex needs are financed with debt”, Moody’s said. Pemex, in response, listed measures it has taken to improve its financial position, including almost US$4bn in budget cuts this year, the sale of noncore assets, and the search for strategic partnerships as per the government’s flagship energy reform. Moody’s noted that Pemex negotiations with the national oil workers’ union will allow the company to reduce its unfunded pension liabilities, which it said should improve Pemex’s capital structure, if not its immediate cash position.