Peru: A change in the captain, not the course
The mid-September resignation of Luis Miguel Castilla as Peru’s economy & finance minister, and his replacement by Alonso Segura Vasi, is unlikely to result in major changes to the country’s longstanding orthodox economic policy stance. Segura’s main challenge is to counter the economic slowdown and make sure that the gains to date – including a sharp reduction in poverty rates – are not eroded before the next scheduled general election in 2016.
Luis Miguel Castilla who formally stepped down for ‘personal reasons’, had overseen the successful management of Peru’s economy since 2011 and had been the longest serving cabinet minister (and was seen by many as being the most influential.
Castilla was replaced by Alonso Segura Vasi, the top economic adviser at the economy & finance ministry (MEF), and a former official of the International Monetary Fund (IMF). Segura had collaborated closely with Castilla since his arrival at the MEF in 2013. Segura is unlikely to make major changes to economic policy in the short- or medium-term. Whether or not Castilla – who publicly applauded Segura’s appointment – exerts an influence from outside cabinet remains to be seen. Either way, orthodox economic policies appear likely to prevail.
Segura is now tasked with implementation of the latest economic stimulus package seeking to boost investment and private sector economic activity. As chart 1 shows, overall growth has slowed markedly in recent months, with the year-on-year increase in real GDP slipping from 5.1% in Q1 14 to 1.7% in Q2. Partly, this has been the result of a deceleration in government consumption growth, which went from a pacey 9.8% to 4.9% year-on-year. Because of a slippage in the prices of major export commodities (particularly copper), exports were 5.1% lower than they were in Q2 13. This has weighed both on government spending and also on corporate investment, which was down 2.6% in Q2 14 over the corresponding year-earlier period.
| Chart 1: Peru's economy: key metrics | ||
| Year-on-year growth (%) in real terms |
1Q14 | 2Q14 |
| GDP | 5.1 | 1.7 |
| Private consumption | 5.1 | 4.2 |
| Public consumption | 9.8 | 4.9 |
| Gross domestic investment | -0.5 | -2.6 |
| Exports | 3.0 | -5.1 |
| Imports | -0.7 | -2.1 |
| Production | 0.3 | 1.2 |
| Rate (%) | ||
| Unemployment | 5.6 | 6.1 |
| Growth in nominal salaries (urban) | 0.0 | 1.8 |
| Growth in nominal wages (urban) | -2.1 | 4.0 |
| CPI inflation | 3.3 | 2.7 |
| PPI inflation | 1.2 | 0.6 |
| Source: BCRP | ||
Most other metrics are reasonably favourable. Overall output has still been rising, led by the services sector. Inflation has come down. The main index of consumer prices (CPI) slipped from 3.3% in Q1 14 to 2.7% in Q2. For the producer price index (PPI), the corresponding figures were 1.2% and 0.6%. However, the unemployment rate has risen slightly, and urban salary earners have suffered a fall in real incomes. This, along with general antipathy towards the political class over another spate of corruption scandals, has contributed to a renewed decline in the popularity of President Ollanta Humala. In the latest (September) poll commissioned by the national daily El Comercio, the president’s approval rating had dropped four percentage points to 25%, reversing an upwards trend evident through July and August. Castilla’s approval rating, moreover, had dropped five percentage points to 20%, the lowest of any cabinet minister.
Chart 2: Real growth year-on-year (%), January-July 2014
Source: BCRP
The latest figures published by the Banco Central de Reserva del Perú (BCRP, central bank) indicate that the economy would have been a lot weaker but for the growth in the services sector and, in particular, in financial services and insurance. As chart 2 shows, the economy posted overall real annual growth of 3.0% in the first seven months of this year. Primary sectors (including agriculture & fisheries and minerals & energy) have been stagnant, as has the manufacturing sector. However output in the services and commerce sectors (wholesale and retail trade) rose by 4.7% and 6.0% year-on-year respectively. This matters, because the two combined account for about half of the entire economy. Manufacturing (including utilities) is the next largest sector, generating about 17% of output. Chart 3 provides the details.
Chart 3: Components of Peru's GDP (%), 2013
Source: BCRP
Consumption is being boosted by the growth in financial services – from a fairly low level of development. As chart 4 shows, total lending to Peru’s private sector grew by 12.7% over the year to August 2014. Lending to companies and to individuals rose by similar amounts. Within corporate lending, credits to large and medium-sized entities have grown by 15.4% and 19.75 respectively. The main area of weakness has been in lending to small and micro-businesses. The low availability of credit for the smallest (i.e. one-person or family) enterprises almost certainly has contributed to the adverse assessment by many Peruvians of the economy’s current performance.
| Chart 4: Year-on-year growth in credit to private sector (%), August 2014 | |
| Loans to companies | 12.9 |
| Corporates and large companies | 15.4 |
| Medium-sized enterprises | 19.7 |
| Small businesses | 1.7 |
| Loans to individuals | 12.4 |
| Consumer loans | 11.8 |
| Car loans | 7.6 |
| Credit cards | 11.5 |
| Mortgage | 13.2 |
| TOTAL | 12.7 |
| Source: BCRP | |
There is plenty that the government can do to boost demand, even if prices of commodity exports remain soft (whether because of stagnation in China’s manufacturing sector or some other reason). The IMF estimates that government revenues and spending will be broadly balanced this year, at around 21% of GDP each. It expects that general government net debt will fall to 3.2% this year, from 3.5% of GDP in 2013. The current account deficit is also falling relative to GDP. At a forecast 4.8% for 2014, it is at a level that is manageable for a country set to achieve nominal growth of 5%-6%.
Financial market participants have been relaxed about Peru’s situation. In a country with overall GDP of about US$217bn, foreign reserves amount to around US$65bn and have been broadly unchanged since the beginning of 2013 (prior to which they had been growing quite steadily). The currency has weakened slightly against the US dollar through Q3 14, but only from PEN2.80/US$ to PEN2.86/US$. The BCRP has stabilised the rate by selling foreign currency. Over the last year, yield spreads on Peruvian debt have fallen by 26 basis points (bps) to 156. Across Latin America as a whole, spreads have remained basically unchanged at 393bps. As chart 5 illustrates, local currency interest rates are low and have been falling. US dollar interest rates within Peru reflect the extremely low levels currently prevailing globally. Encouragingly, local banks and customers increasingly are looking to deal in the local currency. Whereas credit in Soles rose 19.2% in the year to August, credit in US dollars increased by just 3.9%, according to the BCRP.
Chart 5: Local currency interest rates (%) Jun-Sep 2014
Source: BCRP
| Key Points |
| US$/PEN has moved from about 2.80 to 2.86 through Q314 - in spite of net sales of forex by BCRP. |
| Net foreign reserves have remained broadly unchanged at about US$65bn. |
| EMBIG Peru spreads down 26 bps to 156bps over year to 16 Septempber. |
| EMBIG Latam spreads down 3 bps to 393bps. |
| Copper price slips from nearly 400c/lb to 313c/lb since January 12. |
In short, with Segura as economy minister, official policies will remain orthodox and expansionary. And fortunately for the unpopular Humala government, there is room for an expansionary stance. In fact Castilla had been criticised for being too slow to react to the soft external scenario despite having fiscal tools at his disposal. In coming months, we expect greater government spending and new initiatives to promote lending – especially to small and micro-enterprises. A further round of stimulus measures will be pro-business, with tax incentives and cuts to bureaucracy. In the event that the global economy is weaker through Q4 14 than most commentators are expecting, the Peruvian government is well placed to cushion the impact. In terms of its economic management, the country’s captain may have changed, but the course has not.
